Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria: Menu, Reviews & More! [Updated]

Lucious Ortiz 23 May 2025

Are you searching for the perfect slice, a culinary experience that transcends the ordinary? Look no further than Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria, where tradition and taste collide to create pizza perfection.

From Jacksonville to Orlando, Madison to Blue Ridge, the name Cucinella's resonates with pizza aficionados who appreciate fresh ingredients, classic techniques, and a commitment to quality. But what makes Cucinella's so special? Is it the hand-tossed, New York-style crust? The perfectly balanced sauce? Or perhaps the generous toppings and unique flavor combinations that leave diners craving more? Let's delve into the world of Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria and uncover the secrets behind its enduring popularity.

Before diving deeper into the specifics of locations, menu items, and customer experiences, let's take a moment to appreciate the history and tradition behind the Cucinella's name. With roots tracing back to 1932, the family's dedication to the art of brick oven pizza-making is evident in every pie. This long-standing commitment to quality and tradition is what sets Cucinella's apart from the countless other pizza options available today.

Category	Information
Name	Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria (Multiple Locations)
Cuisine	Pizza, Italian
Style	New York-style, Brick Oven
Key Features	Hand-tossed dough, Fresh ingredients, Family tradition since 1932
Known Locations	Jacksonville, Madison, Oviedo, Orlando, Blue Ridge
Price Range	$$ (Moderate)
Must-Try Items	Margherita Pizza, Garlic Knots, Calzones, Lasagna, Strombolis
Social Media Presence	Active Facebook page (example: Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria, Madison, Florida)
Website (Example for research)	Restaurant Guru (for reviews and ratings)

One of the Jacksonville locations, owned by Cucinella and his wife Denise, opened on July 5th at 8116 Old Kings Road S., in the Brierwood area of South Jacksonville. This location quickly became a neighborhood favorite, drawing in locals with its authentic flavors and welcoming atmosphere. The opening marked a significant milestone, continuing the family's legacy of brick oven pizza excellence.

But Cucinella's isn't just a Jacksonville phenomenon. In Madison, Florida, Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria enjoys a stellar reputation. With a 4.7 out of 5 rating on Restaurant Guru, based on 978 reviews and 80 photos, it's clear that this location is a hit with locals and visitors alike. Patrons rave about the hand-tossed, New York-style pizza, praising the quality of the ingredients and the skill of the pizzaiolos. The restaurant's Facebook page, boasting thousands of likes and active engagement, further demonstrates its popularity within the community.

Venturing further south, Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria in Orlando is celebrated for its exceptional pizza, featuring a toasty crust, perfect sauce, and delicious cheese and pepperoni toppings. Diners consistently praise the fresh and fantastic sauce, the amazing toppings, and the incredible crust. And don't forget the garlic butter on the crust it's a game-changer! The Orlando location also offers generous portions of other Italian favorites, such as lasagna and strombolis, ensuring there's something for everyone to enjoy.

In Oviedo, Florida, Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizza is a local gem. While primarily a "to go & delivery pizzeria" with "no dine in," the quality of the pizza speaks for itself. One reviewer, upon discovering the connection between the pizzeria and their son's third-grade teacher at Carillon Elementary, exclaimed, "Wow. Cucinella's pizza puts the local pizza franchises to shame!" This sentiment encapsulates the feelings of many who have tasted the difference that comes with authentic, brick oven-baked pizza.

Even in Blue Ridge, Georgia, Cucinella's Pizzeria has made its mark. While online menus may sometimes be outdated (as one customer discovered when their bill didn't match the online price), the overall consensus is that the pizza is good. The importance of checking the most up-to-date pricing information, perhaps on the restaurant's Facebook page, is a key takeaway for potential customers.

No matter the location, certain menu items consistently receive high praise. The garlic knots, served with marinara sauce, are a must-try appetizer. A half-dozen garlic knots typically cost around $4.99. The Margherita pizza, with its simple yet elegant combination of pizza crust, olive oil, garlic, shaved parmesan, tomato slices, and fresh basil, is another crowd-pleaser. A 12-inch Margherita pizza generally costs around $16.99. These classic dishes, prepared with care and attention to detail, are what keep customers coming back for more.

Customer reviews consistently highlight the exceptional service at Cucinella's. Many patrons report having "a wonderful experience," with service that "exceeded my expectations." The staff is often described as "attentive" and willing to "go above and beyond to make sure every detail was perfect." This dedication to customer satisfaction is a crucial component of the Cucinella's experience, ensuring that every visit is a memorable one.

The enduring appeal of Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria lies in its unwavering commitment to quality, tradition, and customer satisfaction. From the hand-tossed dough to the fresh ingredients and the attentive service, every aspect of the Cucinella's experience is designed to delight. Whether you're in Jacksonville, Madison, Orlando, Oviedo, or Blue Ridge, be sure to give Cucinella's a try and discover what all the fuss is about. You might just find your new favorite pizza place.

Beyond the pizza itself, Cucinella's represents a connection to community and family. The numerous mentions of family ties, neighborhood favorites, and generations of pizza-making tradition underscore the importance of these values to the Cucinella's brand. It's not just about the food; it's about the experience, the connection, and the sense of belonging that Cucinella's provides.

One of the defining characteristics of Cucinella's is the emphasis on fresh ingredients. This commitment to quality is evident in every aspect of the pizza, from the sauce to the toppings. By using only the freshest, highest-quality ingredients, Cucinella's ensures that every bite is bursting with flavor. This dedication to quality is what sets Cucinella's apart from other pizza chains that may prioritize cost over taste.

Another key element of the Cucinella's experience is the traditional brick oven. The high heat of the brick oven cooks the pizza quickly and evenly, resulting in a crispy crust and perfectly melted cheese. This traditional cooking method imparts a unique flavor and texture that cannot be replicated in a conventional oven. The brick oven is the heart of Cucinella's, and it plays a vital role in the creation of their exceptional pizza.

The New York-style pizza served at Cucinella's is another defining characteristic. This style is characterized by a thin, foldable crust, a slightly sweet sauce, and a generous amount of cheese. The New York-style pizza is a classic for a reason, and Cucinella's does it exceptionally well. Whether you prefer a simple cheese pizza or a more elaborate creation with multiple toppings, you're sure to find something to love on the Cucinella's menu.

In addition to pizza, Cucinella's also offers a variety of other Italian dishes, such as lasagna, strombolis, and calzones. These dishes are made with the same care and attention to detail as the pizza, ensuring that every meal is a satisfying and delicious experience. The generous portions and flavorful sauces are sure to leave you feeling full and content.

While online menus may not always be completely accurate, a quick visit to the Cucinella's Facebook page can often provide the most up-to-date pricing information. This is especially important for customers who are concerned about price discrepancies. By checking the Facebook page before ordering, you can ensure that you're getting the most accurate information and avoiding any surprises when you receive your bill.

The positive reviews and high ratings that Cucinella's receives across multiple platforms are a testament to the quality of their food and service. Customers consistently praise the delicious pizza, the attentive staff, and the overall welcoming atmosphere. These positive reviews are a powerful indicator of the Cucinella's experience, and they can help potential customers make an informed decision about where to dine.

For those who are looking for a truly authentic and delicious pizza experience, Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria is the perfect choice. With its commitment to quality, tradition, and customer satisfaction, Cucinella's is sure to become your new favorite pizza place. So, the next time you're craving a slice, be sure to head to Cucinella's and experience the magic for yourself.

The success of Cucinella's can also be attributed to their ability to adapt to changing customer preferences. While they maintain their commitment to traditional pizza-making techniques, they also offer a variety of innovative and creative toppings. This allows them to cater to a wide range of tastes and preferences, ensuring that there's something for everyone to enjoy.

In addition to their commitment to quality and innovation, Cucinella's is also actively involved in the communities they serve. They often participate in local events and support local charities, demonstrating their commitment to giving back. This community involvement further strengthens the connection between Cucinella's and its customers, creating a sense of loyalty and goodwill.

The attention to detail that Cucinella's pays to every aspect of its operation is truly remarkable. From the sourcing of ingredients to the training of staff, every step is carefully considered and executed. This commitment to excellence is what sets Cucinella's apart from its competitors and ensures that every customer has a positive experience.

The consistency of quality across all Cucinella's locations is another key factor in their success. Whether you're in Jacksonville, Madison, Orlando, Oviedo, or Blue Ridge, you can expect the same high level of quality and service. This consistency allows customers to trust the Cucinella's brand and to know that they're always going to get a great meal.

The welcoming atmosphere at Cucinella's is another important aspect of the dining experience. The friendly staff and comfortable surroundings create a relaxing and enjoyable environment for customers. Whether you're dining alone or with a group, you're sure to feel welcome and appreciated at Cucinella's.

The value for money that Cucinella's offers is also a significant draw for customers. The generous portions and reasonable prices make Cucinella's an affordable option for families and individuals alike. This value for money, combined with the high quality of the food and service, makes Cucinella's an unbeatable choice.

The online ordering and delivery options offered by Cucinella's make it easy to enjoy their delicious pizza from the comfort of your own home. This convenience is especially appealing to busy families and individuals who don't have time to dine in at the restaurant. The online ordering system is user-friendly and efficient, making it easy to place your order and track its progress.

The social media presence of Cucinella's allows them to connect with their customers on a personal level. They regularly post updates about new menu items, special promotions, and community events. This social media engagement helps to build brand awareness and to foster a sense of community among Cucinella's customers.

In conclusion, Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria is a truly exceptional pizza place that offers a unique and delicious dining experience. With its commitment to quality, tradition, customer satisfaction, and community involvement, Cucinella's is sure to remain a beloved favorite for many years to come. So, the next time you're in the mood for pizza, be sure to give Cucinella's a try you won't be disappointed.

Exploring the nuances of pizza crust, Cucinella's excels. The commitment to hand-tossed, New York-style pizza is evident, and the cooking process in a brick oven only enhances this. Each location ensures that this technique is properly maintained, ensuring that customers receive a crust that is both crispy and chewy. Its this delicate balance that sets Cucinellas apart.

Another aspect that shouldnt be overlooked is the quality of the sauce. Many reviewers note the freshness and flavor that distinguishes Cucinellas pizza. This isnt just about slapping on any generic sauce. Its about using ingredients that complement each other and create a harmonious, memorable experience. The fresh basil and garlic are not just toppings; they're integral flavors.

But what truly makes the pizza at Cucinellas unique is the generosity of the toppings. Whether it's the Margherita with its simplified elegance or a custom creation, the quantity and quality of each ingredient are always noticeable. Its this attention to detail that keeps customers returning. The strombolis and calzones also offer generous portions, adding to the feeling that every meal is both a feast and a good value.

The customer reviews, scattered across websites like Restaurant Guru and social media platforms like Facebook, converge on a single point: consistency. Across all locations, the positive comments about the quality of the service, the fresh ingredients, and the delicious pizza are consistent. This suggests that Cucinellas has established a reliable system and a high standard that each branch diligently adheres to.

The garlic knots, served with the marinara sauce, become more than just appetizers; they become a signature starter. The reviews often single them out as a must-try, underscoring their role in shaping the overall experience at Cucinellas. Its these details that transform a simple meal into a memorable occasion.

The stories that emerge from interactions with the staff, like the one from the Oviedo location where a third-grade teacher was connected to the pizzeria, add a touch of personality and a sense of community. This human element sets Cucinellas apart, transforming each location into a place where people feel valued and connected.

When one customer mentioned a pricing discrepancy, it highlighted the importance of staying updated with information, especially through social media channels like Facebook. Cucinellas recognizes the value of maintaining current information and engaging with its customers. These small acts of attentiveness solidify trust and create a welcoming environment.

Another key aspect is the ability of Cucinellas to blend tradition with modern sensibilities. Despite the commitment to classic techniques and recipes, they embrace online ordering and delivery services. This adaptability allows them to cater to a wider audience while maintaining the quality and character that defines their pizzas.

In essence, Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria provides more than just pizza; it offers a taste of tradition, a slice of community, and an experience that blends quality and connection. The blend of hand-tossed crusts, fresh ingredients, friendly service, and attention to detail has etched the Cucinella's name in the memories of countless pizza lovers from Jacksonville to Blue Ridge. This lasting legacy continues, one delicious slice at a time.